To me, educational technology is implementing and facilitating technology to enhance learning in a classroom setting but not necessarily a classroom in a physical sense. I think of all the definitions that were stated, the closest one to mine would be the latest AECT definition that states:
Educational technology is the study and ethical practice of facilitating learning nad improving performance by creating, using, and managing appropriate technological processes and resources. (Dempsey p. 4)My definition is based on previous courses in educational technology and my experiences teaching in the classroom. I try to utilize educational technology in my classroom and have seen the difference of when it enhances and when it distracts from the lesson. The book did not alter my definition of educational technology but did enlighten me to a more instructional design aspect of the definition. I have always seen educational technology as an end user and not a designer. Looking at educational technology from a design aspect is a little overwhelming right now because the book seems to be approaching the topic from a large scale instructional design.
I recently designed a lesson that I considered to be technology educational-ish. When reflecting on the geometry lesson and whether or not it adhered to the six characteristics of instructional design, I see that the lesson probably only adhered to half of the characteristics. I felt like my design was student centered because they were required to do all the work and I was only there to answer questions. It was a real-world math problem so the product was a number so that is goal oriented but I tried to have them present the end result in a technologically creative way and that was not a clear goal for them. Students were measured on their meaningful performance but the measure was not clear for them as well. Outcomes were not measured in a reliable and valid way. This was the main problem with the design, so I plan to go back and redesign to reconstruct this aspect of the design. I am not sure how empirical, iterative and self-correcting applies to my design and I designed this lesson on my own. To improve the design, I would create a rubric that would clearly define the learning outcomes for the students.
Instructional media to me would be a "better" way to deliver a lesson to a student. When we discuss the "luxuries" in life, we do not consider a basic roof over our head and basic clothes and beans and rice to be luxuries. To me, the teacher, the chalkboard and textbooks are the basic essentials to a classroom environment. The Promethean board is to the chalkboard as the penthouse is to the efficiency apartment. When I first started reading the textbook, I believed that it was only talking about technology but as I read through chapter 3, it barely mentioned technology. So, instructional design is not about instructional media. Instructional media is a very small part of a very large process.
I love your last paragraph with the analogy. I especially like the way you phrased "Instructional media is a very small part of a very large process." I believe that it is all a cohesive balance. Technology and media are much more than videos and power points.
ReplyDeleteCasey, I have to agree, the analogy at the end of your blog post is great! It really puts in to perspective the difference of these two elements. Instructional design is much more than simply incorporating technology into our lesson plans and syllabi, it's advancing to a higher level of learning...and as great as it sounds, it cannot be introduced without the core: educators.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with you about instructional media being a better way to deliver a lesson. The chalkboard and teacher are essential to the learning process but it is a very small part in the grand scheme of learning. As I was reading the chapters I had my definition of educational technology in my head, and I was comparing it to their definitions. I can honestly say it didn't make me change mine it just sort of "enlightened" it as you said.
ReplyDelete