Thursday, July 3, 2014

Directions and emerging technologies for Instructional Design and Technology


My current position in the IDT field is a teacher.  The current emerging technologies that are well developed for the classroom is web 2.0 technologies and networks.  There are Web 2.0 technologies such as twitter that can be used for students to ask questions during a lesson without being embarrassed to speak in front of the class.   Teachers can ask questions during class to have a discussion behind the scenes.   One way for great learning is to reflect on what you have learned. A Web 2.0 tool great for this would be an eportfolio on a website builder like weebly. The eportfolio would allow for them to look back at what they have produced and write a reflection on what they learned.  Edmodo is a Web 2.0 tool that is like a educational social network like Facebook but with more educational attributes. This could be utilized to connect students on an educational format. I also use rich media by the way of instructional videos to deliver content lesson.  This rich media can be beneficial to students who can watch on their own time with no distractions and pause, rewind and playback at their convenience.  I have been intrigued with the idea of gaming in education.  Since most all students are familiar and infatuated with gaming, this would be an excellent tool if it were to be developed to take students higher in their understanding and not just drill and practice.  The goals and objectives for the technologies would be to deepen the understanding of the mathematical concepts presented in class.  All these methods could facilitate attainment of deepening their understanding of the concept if utilized correctly.  It is important that the facilitator use the tool to go deeper and not just entertain or "engage" the students.  For example, using the rich media of instructional videos allows for more time in class to explore, discuss, practice, collaborate and go deeper into the content than the teacher spending so much time in class trying to get the students to be quiet and listen.

These new technologies can be utilized to better facilitate the learner however there are other issues to consider.  For example, twitter can better enhance the classroom however, there are ethical issues to consider.  Twitter is an open forum and cannot be controlled easily.  Also, if I were to have a discussion on twitter in one class, then another class could look at that discussion to answer questions.  While this is not a huge ethical concern, it could be detrimental to the purpose intended.  I have also seen several news stories where the teacher would post items on the twitter account that was not necessarily pertaining to a lesson which raises the concern of the line between the teacher/student relationship.  I do not see any other ethical issues on the other technologies discussed above because they were designed in an educational setting with ethics considered.  Another issue to consider is the rich media being used a "homework" instead of a worksheet being the "homework".  In low socioeconomic areas, many students do not have access to the internet in their homes.  While this can be worked around, even the "working around" can be an issue in these situations.  For example, I had a student who did not have access to the internet at home and could not come in before or after school because she was the only one who could pick up her siblings and cousins from school.  I tried to make DVD's that the students could watch at home on their gaming systems or DVD players, but some still did not have those either.  This is a problem with accessibility. Most of these technologies discussed above are very intuitive and do not require much guidance at all.  My goal for next year is to find a way to take students to higher order thinking with some technology for EVERY lesson using these technologies.

Friday, June 27, 2014

Trends and issues in IDT

1. Chapters in Section V identify trends and issues in IDT in various contexts: business & industry; military; health care education; P-12 education; and post-secondary education. Select at least 3 of these 5 contexts and compare/contrast the IDT trends and issues. Then explain how they are similar or different from the IDT trends and issues in the context in which you work.


Instructional design and technology is used in many fields but look different depending on which field you are in.  For example, in the business industry, there is usually one person who works as the instructional designer to create training for professionals based on the clients needs but has to coordinate with many people to make it all come together.  Usually the instructional designer has to work with the content expert, the client's representative about money and time and may need to correspond with other professionals in his/her field for support.  The training is usually very specific and for one client.  

In the military, again there is usually one instructional designer but there are many more obstacles that the designer faces.  The instructional designer must understand the clients needs but understand how to made the design work for differing training and not just the one presented at the time.  In the military, there is money issues that may not be as prevalent in the business world.  The designer would need to be knowledgeable about what can be sacrificed in one design so they can splurge on another design to meet their needs and the budget.

In the P-12 arena, typically the designer is the teacher.  The teacher, for the most part, is not a well equipped designer.  They lack the funds, resources and knowledge to meet the clients needs (the students).  Monetarily, the military and P-12 are similar. 

I work in the P-12 division, therefore I am an instructional designer attempting to utilize technology to meet the needs of our future generation.   I do get support from my district to help incorporate technology but the resources are still lacking.  For example, the district installed WiFi to support devices in the classroom however, the students have to bring their own devices and not all devices can do the same things.  We have had trainings to help incorporate technology but it is more of a "check this technology out" and it is up to the "designer" to figure out how to incorporate it into the classroom for their class.  This can be time consuming and is a multifaceted problem with home access for students an issue, classroom management, and others.

 
2. Chapters in Section VI discuss global trends and issues in IDT. As the world’s population grows exponentially, we face unprecedented challenges that have implications for learning. How and can we prepare our youth to address the problems of living in a world with 9 billion people when the earth’s resources cannot sustain that many? Does our current education system, curriculum, and instructional practices help learners foster the complex problem-solving skills necessary to tackle these issues? Are there methods and practices used in European and Asian countries that we should use here in the US? Why or why not? 

It seems that the only country that is ahead of the US is Korea in the arena of instructional design and technology.  Korea has many schools that offer degrees in IDT at the 4yr, 6yr and 8yr level which is different than most countries.  The consensus of the authors of "Trends and Issues in instructional design and technology" is that all countries are lacking in instructional design especially in the educational world.  We do need to concentrate on problem-solving skills and higher order understanding but it seems that most countries are still very traditional.  The US seems to the leading the way in constructivist learning.  I believe if we continue to education incoming teachers with constructivist ideals and keep headed on that path, we will be better off in the future.  We still have time.  We are not doomed yet.

Friday, June 20, 2014

Instructional Design Evaluation




  • Chapters in Section III discuss evaluation in instructional design and provide you with three evaluation models: CIPP, Five-Domain, and Kirkpatrick’s Training Evaluation model. Search for at least two other models used for evaluation and summarize these models. Describe how you would use them to evaluate your instruction. 
    The Jerold Kemp instructional design method
  • The Jerold Kemp instructional design method
    The Jerold Kemp instructional design method
    1. Identify instructional problems, and specify goals for designing an instructional program.
    2. Examine learner characteristics that should receive attention during planning.
    3. Identify subject content, and analyze task components related to stated goals and purposes.
    4. State instructional objectives for the learner.
    5. Sequence content within each instructional unit for logical learning.
    6. Design instructional strategies so that each learner can master the objectives.
    7. Plan the instructional message and delivery.
    8. Develop evaluation instruments to assess objectives.
    9. Select resources to support instruction and learning activities. 
source: http://www.instructionaldesigncentral.com/htm/IDC_instructionaldesignmodels.htm 
 
According to the Jarold Kemp instructional design method as listed above, there are nine steps to instructional design.  This one starts out by identifying the problem, this is different than most design evaluations.  This is similar to the educational model of "backwards design" where the designer starts by identifying the goals for the lesson rather than the objectives.

  • Reflect on what other questions that instructional design evaluation should address besides whether the instructional design leads to comparable amounts of learning and learner satisfaction as traditional methods. Should return on investment and management of resources also be considered in evaluations of instructional programs? What other measures should/could be considered?
In most cases, instructional design evaluations compare to other types of design models but I am not sure if that is the best approach.  The evaluation measures if there is comparable amounts of learning and if the student is satisfied with the approach.  Why is it the case where the more they learn the better quality the design?  I find myself, cramming information into my students for the upcoming tests and they do not have a clue as to why and how these concepts are applicable to anything.  They "learned" many things but do not appreciate or have a deep understanding of the concepts.  I believe that another measure that should be considered is the rigor of the learning of the material, but it should also be more that just rigor.  Many curricula are very rigorous but the scaffolding to reach all students is not there.  I realize that this is the job of the instructor but it should also be built into the instructional design for the instructor to utilize.
  • Section IV focuses on human performance, performance support systems, knowledge management systems, and the concept of informal learning. Not all problems in learning and/or performance require an instructional one. Many times a non-instructional approach is a more appropriate solution. Identify a performance problem in your area of work and identify non-instructional solutions that may help solve the problem. Would better performance support systems, knowledge management systems, or opportunities for informal learning solve the problem?
The biggest problem that I have in the classroom is motivation of the students.  While the direct teaching style that is currently used may be much of the problem, I believe it has to do with the students' self-concept in mathematics and the relevance of the coursework for them personally.  Some days I can see the dread in the faces of my students as they enter the door.  I have taken non-instructional approaches to help alleviate their "agony".  Towards the second half of the year, once my consistent classroom management was established, I began relaxing during the lesson and joking around with the students.  While walking around, assisting with individual practice, I would begin to have personal conversations with the students.  This seemed to help somewhat and some students began working harder.  Another thing I did was to show short 5 minute videos as the students entered the classroom.  Sometimes it was relevant to the lesson and sometimes it was just for fun.  So I have tried non-instructional solutions but next year I will continue with what I have done but add instructional solutions as well, such as more student-centered instruction.

Thursday, June 12, 2014

Theories and models of learning and instruction




3. Differing epistemic stances lead to differing approaches to learning and instruction, and ultimately to problem-solving. Explain differences in problem-solving when approached from behaviorist and constructivist perspectives. How do the approaches differ in both the nature of the problem to be solved and in facilitating the problem solving process? Finally, what effect might these differences have on learner motivation?

Epistemology is the study of how we come to know things.  There are theories on different ways that people learn better such as Piaget's, Vygotsky's "zone of proximal development", Gagne and Skinner's theories.  There are methods to present information to a learner such as project-based method, problem-based method, discovery method, as well as model-eliciting problems are just some examples.  While these are all related to each other, but they differ in their make up.  Epistemology is just the field of study of how we know things.  This is the most general idea.  Theories are an idea of how the brain works to learn new concepts.  Methods are possible solutions to solving the theories of learning.

 Of the three epistemic stances of positivist, relativist and contextualist, I believe I fall between the positivist and relativist but closer to relativist.  I am a math major and a math teacher so math is math and it is what it is so I tend to be very black and white by nature but I am a very open minded person who always sees both sides before making a decision.  I say this to explain why I am in between the two theories.  I have taken courses based on constructivist and "lecture style".  I believe I learned so much more from the constructivist approach and had much more appreciation for the subject matter.  I struggled with a undergrad course that was intended for sophomores.  I could not understand the content even though I spend endless hours in tutoring and reading and practicing.  This course was calculus 2.  I could not make the connections needed between topics and could not understand what the calculus method was doing.  I do believe that this was due to the opposing epistemic stances.  Typically, math instructors, especially "experienced" ones are very positivist in nature.  Math is math and it is what it is.  But I believe that there is beauty in math and when we "discover" it, it becomes so much more beautiful.

Thursday, June 5, 2014

Defining the Instructional Design Field


     To me, educational technology is implementing and facilitating technology to enhance learning in a classroom setting but not necessarily a classroom in a physical sense.  I think of all the definitions that were stated, the closest one to mine would be the latest AECT definition that states:
Educational technology is the study and ethical practice of facilitating learning nad improving performance by creating, using, and managing appropriate technological processes and resources. (Dempsey p. 4)
My definition is based on previous courses in educational technology and my experiences teaching in the classroom.  I try to utilize educational technology in my classroom and have seen the difference of when it enhances and when it distracts from the lesson.  The book did not alter my definition of educational technology but did enlighten me to a more instructional design aspect of the definition.  I have always seen educational technology as an end user and not a designer.  Looking at educational technology from a design aspect is a little overwhelming right now because the book seems to be approaching the topic from a large scale instructional design.

     I recently designed a lesson that I considered to be technology educational-ish.  When reflecting on the geometry lesson and whether or not it adhered to the six characteristics of instructional design, I see that the lesson probably only adhered to half of the characteristics.  I felt like my design was student centered because they were required to do all the work and I was only there to answer questions.  It was a real-world math problem so the product was a number so that is goal oriented but I tried to have them present the end result in a technologically creative way and that was not a clear goal for them.  Students were measured on their meaningful performance but the measure was not clear for them as well.  Outcomes were not measured in a reliable and valid way.  This was the main problem with the design, so I plan to go back and redesign to reconstruct this aspect of the design.  I am not sure how empirical, iterative and self-correcting applies to my design and I designed this lesson on my own.  To improve the design, I would create a rubric that would clearly define the learning outcomes for the students.

     Instructional media to me would be a "better" way to deliver a lesson to a student.  When we discuss the "luxuries" in life, we do not consider a basic roof over our head and basic clothes and beans and rice to be luxuries.  To me, the teacher, the chalkboard and textbooks are the basic essentials to a classroom environment.  The Promethean board is to the chalkboard as the penthouse is to the efficiency apartment.  When I first started reading the textbook, I believed that it was only talking about technology but as I read through chapter 3, it barely mentioned technology.  So, instructional design is not about instructional media.  Instructional media is a very small part of a very large process.