Thursday, June 12, 2014

Theories and models of learning and instruction




3. Differing epistemic stances lead to differing approaches to learning and instruction, and ultimately to problem-solving. Explain differences in problem-solving when approached from behaviorist and constructivist perspectives. How do the approaches differ in both the nature of the problem to be solved and in facilitating the problem solving process? Finally, what effect might these differences have on learner motivation?

Epistemology is the study of how we come to know things.  There are theories on different ways that people learn better such as Piaget's, Vygotsky's "zone of proximal development", Gagne and Skinner's theories.  There are methods to present information to a learner such as project-based method, problem-based method, discovery method, as well as model-eliciting problems are just some examples.  While these are all related to each other, but they differ in their make up.  Epistemology is just the field of study of how we know things.  This is the most general idea.  Theories are an idea of how the brain works to learn new concepts.  Methods are possible solutions to solving the theories of learning.

 Of the three epistemic stances of positivist, relativist and contextualist, I believe I fall between the positivist and relativist but closer to relativist.  I am a math major and a math teacher so math is math and it is what it is so I tend to be very black and white by nature but I am a very open minded person who always sees both sides before making a decision.  I say this to explain why I am in between the two theories.  I have taken courses based on constructivist and "lecture style".  I believe I learned so much more from the constructivist approach and had much more appreciation for the subject matter.  I struggled with a undergrad course that was intended for sophomores.  I could not understand the content even though I spend endless hours in tutoring and reading and practicing.  This course was calculus 2.  I could not make the connections needed between topics and could not understand what the calculus method was doing.  I do believe that this was due to the opposing epistemic stances.  Typically, math instructors, especially "experienced" ones are very positivist in nature.  Math is math and it is what it is.  But I believe that there is beauty in math and when we "discover" it, it becomes so much more beautiful.

3 comments:

  1. Casey
    You know I concluded the same thing when I was reading about epistemology – it’s similar to Piaget's/Vygotsky's & Gagne and Skinner's theories where the data/strategies presented are different approaches, but ultimately the study is about what people learned, and how they got to their “knowledge point”.

    I can see how you would relate most to being a relativist. Math is math – and you’re right. There’s no inbetween and no maybes; it’s one answer, one absolute :)

    Overall I believe that whether we approach it through an epistemic, or instructional methods, we are approaching it with a particular belief of what will work and how, just as Piaget and Vygotsky did.

    Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with your definitions of epistemology and instructional theories. To say that I was a bit confused at the beginning of this week's assignment would be an understatement, but having read through blog posts like yours is definitely helping me make sense of it all. I, too, relate to more of a relativist theory perspective. I believe that, for the most part, we as human learners naturally build on our knowledge base and relate new concepts to what we already understand. This is a different process for everyone, since we all have had different experiences and diferent backgrounds. However, I am also finding that there is not necessarily one theory that matches every learner in every situation. In order to grow as learners, we must adapt and be open-minded, allowing ourselves to understand new ideas in order to be the best role models for our students. We must also 'discover,' as you say, along with our students to truly show them the beauty of learning.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Casey,

    I am in the same boat with you as someone who majored in mathematics and thinks along relativist lines. Perhaps most of us who are of the analytical nature think similarly; we rely on our "knowledge bank" to help guide us in making decisions or solving problems. My wife is not this way and it drives her crazy; she doesn't understand why I must do a cost-benefit analysis of every decision we make!

    Calculus II was one of the most difficult math courses that I took so I applaud you for sticking to it! I had a great instructor, though, and was able to learn well with his linear style of teaching. The following semester in Linear Algebra, I had an instructor who was all over the place; I had a very difficult time keeping up in his lectures. Although math is typically black and white, there are sometimes multiple approaches to finding a solution (or solutions.) It is important that we emphasize this to students; who knows when one of them will find a novel way of solving problems!

    Great post!

    Todd Gruhn

    ReplyDelete